Pinellas Sheriff’s Office Doesn’t Deserve Reaccreditation
Posted on Friday, 16 of October , 2009 at 6:39 pm
COMMENTARY
PINELLAS COUNTY, FLA–In his infamous Gettysburg Address, Abraham Lincoln orated “that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom….and that government of the people, by the people, and for the people, shall not perish from the earth”.
It’s time for the people of Pinellas County, Florida, to enforce that these words are as strong today as they were 140 years ago. Government is of the people, by the people and for the people—not the political powers that be.
Some 45 years ago a unanimous Supreme Court declared: “The historic phrase ‘a government of laws and not of men’ epitomizes the distinguishing character of our political society….[L]aw alone saves a society from being…ruled by mere brute power however disguised.”
According to an announcement on the website of the Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office, a team of assessors from the Commission on Accreditation for Law Enforcement Agencies Inc. (CALEA) will arrive in Clearwater on Oct. 17 to examine all aspects of the Sheriff’s Office policies, procedures, management, operations and support services. These inspections occur every three years.
The on-site assessment team will consist of Chief (Ret.) Thomas Clark, Jr. of the Mechanicsville Police Department, Mechanicsville, Va., and Captain Nancy Dietz of the Wilmington Police Department, Wilmington, Del.
Agency members and citizens are invited to offer comments on Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office services at a public information session scheduled for 7 p.m., on Monday, Oct.19.
The session will be conducted at the Criminal Justice Center, located at 14250 49th Street North, Clearwater.
For those persons who cannot attend the public session, they may still provide comments to the assessment team by telephone. The assessors will receive telephone calls from 3 to 5 p.m., Monday, Oct. 19. Members of the public are asked to call 727-582-6033 to speak to an assessor.
In each case, citizens will be given 10 minutes to offer their comments, which should address the ability of the Sheriff’s Office to comply with the standards set by CALEA.
Citizens who wish to submit written comments can address them to CALEA at the address listed above.
In our view, the Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office and Sheriff Jim Coats has some tough questions to answer and quite frankly, considering the alleged handling of the Terri Schiavo case, the deaths at the Pinellas County Jail and the homicides and serious incidents occurring due to the department use of tasers
In July 2007, Pinellas-Pasco state attorney Bernie McCabe cleared seven officers of the Pinellas County Sheriff’s Department in the May 5, 2007 death of Daniel Bradley Young, 34, of Largo. McCabe ruled that Young’s death was an “excusable homicide”. Young was tasered by several of the officers.
An autopsy conducted by the Sixth Circuit medical examiner’s office said there were several puncture marks on Young’s body that were consistent with marks from a Taser but that Young died as result of “excited delirium syndrome”, a “pre-existing condition” due to cocaine toxicity.
Months later, McCabe once again ruled that the victim’s death was an “excusable homicide” and that despite the officers punching Young and tasering him, that the deputies didn’t cause Young’s death, apparently wanting the public to believe that Young would have died anyway, regardless of the police intervention and presence.
In announcing McCabe’s refusal to prosecute the seven officers, the sheriff’s department press release said that Young’s death occurred while the officers, “believing Young met Baker Act criteria, were in the performance of their lawful, legal duties of taking Young into custody”.
The police report said that Young was Tasered and as he continued to struggle, a deputy struck him with a closed fist in the face and throat. Another deputy got a handcuff on one of Young’s hands and she then Tasered Young in the lower back and then in the stomach.
Young, the brother of Pinellas County Jail detention deputy Randall Young, was allegedly wandering in his neighbors’ yards, walking back and forth across Park Blvd. from his residence, speaking incoherently, shedding his clothing and collecting and carrying objects from the yards of his neighbors to his residence.
Police said that when Young was told he was under arrest, he became combative, a struggle ensued and officers tasered him. He became unresponsive and was transported to the Largo Medical Center where he was pronounced dead.
Young was the second man to die that week at the hands of officers of the Pinellas County Sheriff’s Department. McCabe cleared them all.
Deputy Christopher Taylor shot drug suspect Jarrell Walker twice in the back, but although McCabe said that the sheriff’s department needed to review its policy on deadly force—instituted by former sheriff Everett Rice—that the Taylor killing of Walker was, guess what—yep—justifiable homicide.
And just what was Walker doing that justified the police officer shooting him in the back twice? He was lying face down on a couch, with his hand underneath the skirting of the couch. Wasn’t there some other way of containing Mr. Walker than shooting him in the back?
Other officers found no gun or weapon under the couch.
Rice hired Taylor in 1998 and he was involved in two previous shootings. Instead of reassigning Taylor, Rice allowed him to remain on the SWAT team and ultimately the officer took a black man’s life—-but it was justified according to McCabe.
In May, 2000, Taylor shot a man who allegedly interfered with the investigation of a shoplifting suspect in a Seminole parking lot. In April, 2004, he was one of two deputies who shot at a truck driver who snagged a sheriff’s patrol car under a boat trailer. No deaths were involved in those incidents but in both cases, McCabe and Rice cleared Taylor of wrongdoing.
In 2005, even McCabe said the Pinellas Sheriff’s deadly force policy had a problem—-and then the FBI opened an investigation into whether Walker’s civil rights were violated.
Then there was the case of Charles Faybik. He’s lucky to be alive.
He almost wasn’t due to the actions of the Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office who sent six deputies to the 75-year-old man’s house because they thought he might be suicidal.
Claiming that they were assisting Faybik, they forced entry to his house and shot him in the stomach with three Taser guns, two jolts each for a total of six electrified hits, leaving burn marks on his stomach. The Taser produces 26 watts of power transmitted through two electrified prongs. He’s lucky he didn’t suffer a heart attack.
Now he’s suing Sheriff Jim Coats and the sheriff’s office for use of excessive force and violation of his civil rights…….and rightfully so. Faybik’s attorney, John Trevena, says the officers weren’t properly trained. Coats says that there’s nothing in department policy that restricts the use of Tasers on senior citizens.
The accreditation team needs to take a long hard look at the training and departmental policy.
Faybik, who is blind in one eye and hard of hearing, says he initially didn’t hear the officers when they knocked on his door. Depressed due to the holidays, Faybik had been talking on the phone with a friend of his on Dec. 28, 2005, and mused he wondered what he would do if he had a gun. He didn’t have one.
That friend’s wife called 911 to warn that Faybik might be suicidal. Deputies claim that when they arrived at the elder’s house, he didn’t initially respond to answer the door and didn’t answer the phone. It was later revealed that the police were calling the wrong number.
When he did finally hear the doorbell and started to open the door, claiming that they were acting under the Baker Act, the officers pushed in the door, shoved the old man backwards using a shield, pushing him to the ground because they said he wouldn’t cooperate and because they couldn’t see what he had in his hands. They zapped him because they said he was “flailing” his arms around.
When the six officers forced open his door, Faybik thought he was being robbed. The officers admitted they knew they Tasered Faybik knowing that he wasn’t armed.
Instead of calling in a crisis intervention team or even trying to talk with the man, the deputies zapped him six times. He posed no threat and had broken no laws.
Naturally Coats and the sheriff’s office says the officers acted properly. As usual in Pinellas County, no disciplinary action was meted out to any of the officers involved.
The sheriff’s office began using Tasers in January 2004 and according to statistics kept by the agency, that year officers used force over 1,400 times, force including the use of pepper spray, Tasers, batons and takedowns. Records indicate that deputies used their Tasers in 22 percent of the incidents. In 2005, in responding to 1,151 uses of force, the frequency of Taser use went up to 47%.
The circumstances surrounding the use of Tasers, excessive force and the resulting deaths are becoming more and more demanding for an investigation of the not only the sheriff’s department but the state attorney’s office.
We don’t believe that accreditation should be reissued to the Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office because professional excellence is seriously lacking within that agency.
A serious look should be taken at the deaths occurring at the Pinellas County Jail where in 2006, inmates were dropping like flies which would seem to raise grave questions about not only about the quality of the medical care rendered and screening procedures at the facility but about the supervision within the jail.
The deaths of five of the six inmates occurred on the 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. shift worked by Michael Schiavo.
It would also appear to be a basis for an outside independent investigation of jail policy, procedures and staff. In 2006, at least six inmates have died while in the custody of Coats and the jail staff which includes the widely known wife killer and euthanasia advocate Michael Schiavo is employed on staff as a registered nurse.
There have been issues of alleged illegal dispensing of prescription medication in the inmate division of the jail where Schiavo is employed and was involved in a case where Diane Cross, a registered nurse and clinical supervisor at the jail, was terminated after Schiavo filed a complaint against her, claiming that she had allegedly dispensed Robaxin, a prescription medication to another nurse and clinical supervisor.
Schiavo himself was also disciplined in the case.
http://www.northcountrygazette.org/2007/10/03/fingers-of-accusation-fuel-schiavo-retaliation/
http://www.northcountrygazette.org/2007/10/27/judge-upholds-nurse-termination-on-schiavo-complaint/
Let’s not forget the death of Dorothy Dian Palinchik at the jail in February 2008. An autopsy showed her cause of death to be severe pneumonia brought on by a massive MRSA infection. Palinchik had been charged with stealing a $9 Philly cheesesteak sandwich from a Publix in St. Petersburg.
MRSA is found in crowded places that have questionable sanitation practices such as jails. She died three days after she was admitted to the jail.
Although she had a fever of 101.5 degrees, the jail staff had allegedly only given her a Motrin and a Sudafed. When a friend visited her at the jail and found her in serious condition, he complained to jail staff but said he was ignored by hostile guards.
Fifteen days after she was booked into the jail, she was dead.
Considering the number of inmate deaths at the jail, it appears that perhaps a state investigation should be conducted and a review of the inmate health care division, detention and corrections bureau where euthanasia advocate Michael Schiavo is employed as a clinical supervisor on the 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. shift.
Accreditation? Not with that number of deaths. Someone needs to take a look at what’s going on at the facility. Maybe the guards are spending too much time surfing the Internet and reading articles about the Schiavo case instead of supervising inmates.
Earlier this year, following an Internal Affairs investigation, it was determined that Michael Schiavo, the man who killed his former wife, Terri Schindler Schiavo, by dehydration, claiming that she would want to die in such an inhumane manner because she was incapacitated, had been using taxpayer-owned sheriff’s department resources and taxpayer time to engage in public attacks on Internet forums, focusing on the Schindler family and others involved in the Schiavo case–in essence–defrauding the taxpayers.
Investigations conducted by both the Administrative Investigations Division of the Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office and the command level of the Detention and Corrections Division substantiated that Schiavo violated department policy and for a period of nearly six months, had routinely been posting derogatory messages, even starting threads to post negative comments about the Schindler family and their representatives, wile using department computers during regular work hours.
http://www.northcountrygazette.org/2009/01/25/cyber_slacker/
http://www.northcountrygazette.org/2009/01/31/schiavo_dole/
The accreditation team should also consider the cover-up in the Schiavo case which would lead us to question how many other cover-ups and scuttling of warranted investigations into politically sensitive alleged criminal activity have there been by the Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office and its supervisors. http://www.northcountrygazette.org/2009/10/15/schiavo_culture/
After all, government is still by the people, of the people and for the people and now is the time for the people to speak out and emphatically state that cover-ups and protection of certain politically connected people in the state of Florida and particularly in Pinellas County cannot and will not be tolerated. 10-16-09
STOP! READ! Avoid A Forbidden Notice. First time visitors are welcome at no charge. Thereafter, readers who wish to read additional articles or plan on returning at a later time will need to be an advertiser or have a paid subscription to the NCG Daily Digest in order to gain access. This policy will be strictly enforced and access will be denied to those who abuse it. To sign up, see the subscription ad and PayPal button to the right of this page or at www.northcountrygazette.org If you have questions, contact us at news@northcountrygazette.org
Special subscription rate through Nov. 11, 2009. See http://www.northcountrygazette.org/2009/10/11/changes_coming/
Category: Crime, Florida, Government, Health, Opinion, Police, Schiavo
- Add this post to
- Del.icio.us -
- Meneame -
- Digg
COPYRIGHT 2009 - NORTH COUNTRY GAZETTE All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without the express written permission of the publisher.
